Distillery | Michters | Tastings

Michter’s Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon Review

Last updated Oct 29, 2020 | Published on Aug 29, 2019


by Matty Sims

ProductionSmall batch. Limited quantities.
AgeNon Age Stated (NAS)
First BarrelFire-charred, new American white oak barrels
Second BarrelToasted barrel made from 18-month air-dried wood
Price$49.99 (more than likely higher because of limited availability)
ProsComplex and Surprising
ConsTad Thin
InventoryLimited — Buy for Less than $80

Michter’s Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon was first released in 2015 but it’s been MIA since then, although Michter’s has released a Toasted Barrel Rye in the meantime. This departure is mainly because of the bourbon shortage.

Joseph J. Magliocco, Michter’s President, explained Michter’s Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon’s absence:

“We need to allocate our whiskeys because we just don’t have enough to meet demand. Because of the goods situation we debated whether to do this release. In the end we made the decision to make some Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon for our loyal customers who have been clamoring for it.”

Start shopping for bourbon swag for your journey. The Bard’s Shop has custom tees and hoodies, books, barrels, and more.

Michter’s Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon Review

Michter's Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon

The flavor profile is different than your standard Michter’s Bourbon. It’s unique because of the toast finish. Michter’s second barreling is different than say Old Forester’s 1910 or Woodford’s Double Oaked. This is a toasting, not char. The char develops burnt caramel, sassafras, and oak notes whereas the toasting highlights vanilla and baking spices.

Michter’s Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon In the Glass

It’s not a thick oily bourbon (check out this great read what makes a bourbon oily). It’s got short stubby legs in the glass.


Copper, Orange. Think the bright colors of fall.


Olive Oil Cake, freshly kneaded dough, tart cherry pastry, fresh wood. Reminds me of a kitchen full of freshly baked pies on the Fourth of July.


What’s surprising about the taste is the spice. I get little if any spice on the nose but the first flavor that hits the top of the tongue is peppercorn spice.

Mid palate you got a pop of those baked cherry pies and butterscotch with cinnamon and light smokiness which gives way quickly to oak, white pepper.

Baking spices dance along the top of the palate through back of the throat. The yeast/bread slithers down the side of the palate as the unifiying flavor note.

It’s refreshing and clean.


The finish hits the top of the throat and lingers with a pop of sweet and abundant spice.

Verdict: Silver 88 Points

For those who love a bourbon that’s a bit quirky but full of complex, confusing flavors Michter’s Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon is a can’t-miss hit. If you’re not an adventurous bourbon enthusiast, leave it for next person.

Sneak Peek

Michters Small Batch Bourbon Batched and with Toasted Staves

A buddy from a local bourbon group and I have located five bottles of Michter’s bourbon. He’s a science nerd when it comes to distilling and sells staves at five toast levels (check out Beyond Barrels to buy your staves). Our plan is to use all five toasted staves with a Michter’s bourbon to try to recreate their Toasted Barrel Bourbon.

Results of that will follow in a future post. It should be fun. Leave me your tasting notes in the comments below.

Start shopping for bourbon swag for your journey. The Bard’s Shop has custom tees and hoodies, books, barrels, and more.

Written by Matty Sims

Matty Sims is the Editor-in-Chief at a digital media company. LeAnn (his wife) and his daughters Claire, Maddy, and Adele along with a brand new pup Booker live in Taylors, SC, at the foot of the Blue Ridge Mountains. He enjoys cracking a well-aged bottle of bourbon with friends and sharing stories, or cracking one of his favorite daily sippers on the back porch while the pup and his kids play in the backyard. He is a storyteller at heart, and Bourbon has deep roots in storytelling.

Related Posts

Bulleit Frontier Whisky Review

As the story goes in the 1830s, Tom Bulleit's great great great (you get the picture) grandfather, a tavern keeper in Lousiville, developed a high rye whiskey. But in 1860, as Augustus Bulleit was transporting this whiskey from...

read more

Every Maker’s Mark Bourbon Reviewed [Complete Guide]

Maker's Mark bourbon has a long history within the bourbon industry. Before Bill Samuels created this iconic brand his father was distilling his own whiskey (although reported not very good). The Maker's Mark's legend began when T. William Samuels Sr., bought the...

read more

Wild Turkey 101 Review [2021]

Wild Turkey 101 bourbon has a cult-like following. For Turkey lovers, it can stand up against the best of the best. Honestly, it's a great pour and often overlooked. Wild Turkey 101 is non-age stated but it's a blend of 6 to...

read more

Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey Review [2021]

Jack Daniel's Tennessee Whiskey is one of the world's best selling American whiskeys. It's also polarizing. Some love it. Some love to hate it. Then there is the argument of whether Jack Daniel's is bourbon. We will get to that as...

read more

Every Jim Beam Bourbon Reviewed [2021]

I've decided to spend the next month or so on the bottom shelf of the bourbon dial to truly find out which bottom shelf bourbon is better. Why not start with the OG of the bottom shelf? Jim Beam bourbon or as some people call it Jim Beam White Label. Master of Malt...

read more

Buy Bourbon Clothing

Ask Us About Bourbon



Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Buy Bourbon Clothing & Accessories